Consumers Digest

Is Jordana eyeliner decent?

I usually use a Urban Decay pencil eyeliner, cause I like Sephora products, but I've been on a budget and on MakeupAlley.com, in the reviews, people reviewed their eyeliner to be good. Is it actually good? I'm a little scared to use cheap eyeliners because I've tried the Wet N' Wild ones and they are so sticky, it's appalling. I do like Rimmel pencil liners though. So, how does this one compare? Thanks, I love MAC. I was wondering about the quality of Jordana eyeliner pencils, though, sold at drugstores.

Public Comments

1. I refer to Makeup alley alot myself ...you can get some great information on there ......I don't know much about the urban Decay brand . But I do use MAC Fluidline and I love it. It goes on like a gel with a brush and it dries and looks like a liquid ...it takes a little bit of practice putting it on but once you get it figured out it will not take you long ......It is about $18 and it last a good bit, especially if you keep the lid real tight ...It comes in so many colors too..... I am sending you a link to makeup alley and the reviews on it ...and a link to MAC so you can see the shades .... http://www.makeupalley.com/product/showreview.asp/ItemId=61211/Fluidline_Eye-Liner_Gel_in_Blacktrack/MAC/Eyeliner http://www.maccosmetics.com/templates/products/sp.tmpl?CATEGORY_ID=CATEGORY15101&PRODUCT_ID=PROD7715 Hope some of this is helpful ~~~ EDIT** Here are some sites that have reviews on that brand of eyeliner that I thought might help you ... http://vanillaeyeliner.com/reviews/74?r=index;newreviews&PHPSESSID=0f001ecdba5bddb436ab3ec2c61fe89b http://www.beautyaddictmag.com/thebuzz/barginbeauty/barginindex.html http://www.malaysianbabes.net/forum/Jordana-Eyeliner-t4605.html
2. ok well idk if jordana eyeliner is good but you should get the l'oreal paris kind...i guess it just depends if it soft..bcuz if it says soft on the labling then that means it goes on real easy and dark
3. Jordana is okay, but Rimmel is better for what they're worth, in my opinion. For basic colors I absolutely love Revlon Colorstay eyeliner. The only problem with Colorstay is that its not like pointy and sharp as a pencil, but some find that the twistable end (no need for sharpeners) is a plus. Its long wearing and I give my seal of approval for it, at least in the drugstore range.
4. I use Jordana eyeliner and ever since I started I love it. I hardly use my este lauder eyeliners anymore. Its the twistable and its easy to apply and they come in different colors. Just try it out I'm sure if you try one out it won't hurt your budget that much.