Consumers Digest

Which is better: MAC or Clinique eyeliners?

I'm planning to buy either the clinique brush on cream eyeliner or the MAC fluidline. But i'm so confused. I know they're both the same but I need to know your opinions about these products. I checked makeupalley.com and I noticed there were more great reviews on the clinique one but some ppl also say MAC is better. Also I heard the mac one tends to dry up faster than the clinique and it's not as dark. Which one has more staying power and is easier to take off after the day?

Public Comments

1. MAC!!! It stays on longer and doesnt run like Clinique
2. mac !!! it will last longer, i've heard 4 girls say clinique broke out thier face
3. Buy MAC. The tip of the appilicator is more durable and its a little cheaper than Cliniques. It lasts longer too.
4. Definitely MAC. It lasts longer and for me, it works really well on my lashes (makes them look longer). I tried a free sample of clinique before and it didn't enhance the look of my lashes as well as MAC did.
5. I'm using the clinique brush on cream eyeliner right now, and it works great! I love it. But I haven't tried MAC yet, so I can't really tell you which is better =/
6. I say MAC, I own a lot of their products. I like what they do when it comes to having no rules about makeup. You should wear the colors you want and i also support them in the fight for a cure for aids.
7. definately mac
8. MAC lasts longer bt I find Clinique is good for contact lens users or those with extremely sensitive eyes.
9. Mac fluidline
10. well, mac and clinique are made by the same company, so they are lbasically the same products in different packaging, with different names, and maybe a few different colors in each line. they both worked the same for me.