Consumers Digest

Wet 'n' Wild Mega Eyes Creme Liner VS. Maybelline Gel Eyeliner?

So I went on makeupalley.com to see which one had better reviews, Wet 'n' Wild had more about 400 reviews and Maybelline had only about 100. Both had a 4.5 rating and their percentage for "buying this product again" was only a 1% difference. So that being said... In your experience which one was better? I want to try them since people said that they are similar to MAC Fluidline and Bobbi Brown's. Describe the product, too if you would, thanks!

Public Comments

1. Im not really a fan of wet and wild products because they always seem cheaper made and not as good quality. The maybelline gel eyeliner is your best bet it also comes with a great brush and is the closest to mac and bobbi browns
2. definitely get the wet n wild creme liner!!!!!!.....i just bought it a few days ago and i luuuuv it!!!!.........it works so good.....definitely the best gel/creme eyeliner ive used so far.....it only cost 4 bucks tooo!!!!......but right now in rite aid they are having a 40 percent off any wet n wild product....so this is like the best time to try it!