Consumers Digest - I want to buy this mascara product, some reviews say they get clumps and others don't, why is that?

I want to buy this mascara product, some reviews say they get clumps and others don't, why is that?

I'm at the Sephora site, and I want to buy Dior DiorShow Mascara for $24. And some reviews say they get clumps and some say they don't. Why is that?! Actually, I was at the wrong site, it's $31... Canadian one

Public Comments

diferrent textures of eyelashes react differently to certain products
Dior Show is actually one of the best mascaras this year. Remember that everyone has different opinion on things. If I were you, I would go to Sephora and try it on myself. See how you look, if you like the texture, etc. Good luck :)
Sometimes it is how old the tube is. A fresher tube is always better. One that was on the shelf a long time might be thicker. If you shop at Sephora, here's a way to earn cash back. It is a site called Ebates. You sign up for free and get $5 just for joining. You don't have to give your credit card info. Here's a referral to get your $5: http://www.ebates.com/rf.do?referrerid=gG3Hu6z%2FuX95WBPB5ln0cA%3D%3D You'll get cash back on your purchase at Sephora. After signing up, just go to Ebates, and click the link to Sephora from there. Also, I like Sephora because they have a great return policy. If you buy the mascara and it clumps, you can return it, no questions asked, even if you used it. Same with perfumes from Sephora. If you buy it and hate it, you can take it back. Great customer service!
Try MAC Studio Fix Mascara - Its only $13 and its RIDICULOUS!! Everybody i try it on buys it!
I use lustrafy mascara, it is only 16.95. Ive used Dior, Lancome, and YSL and none of them compare to lustrafy. you can get it online at http://www.motivescosmetics.com/preciousrose/index.cfm?action=shopping.csProductDetail&groupID=5_CS_CAN&cat2ID=CAN21129&cat3ID=CAN32348 The trick when using this mascara is when you apply it, apply it on top of the lashes, not underneath like we usually do. The brush is really good at evenly coating the lashes to make them thick and long when you use this technique. after you brush on top, evenly coating the lashes, brush underneath to curl up the lashes. After I started using this mascara, I don't even bother with a eye lash curler.